Welcome to A Touch of Italy, a hidden gem nestled in Amityville, NY, where authentic Italian flavors meet a cozy, casual dining experience. At this charming pizzeria located at 355 Broadway, you’ll discover a delightful array of Italian cuisine, anchored by their specialty pizzas and brick oven pizzelle.

Stepping into A Touch of Italy, you’re greeted by the warmth of a small pizzeria exuding a friendly atmosphere perfect for families and groups alike. With on-site parking and outdoor seating, it’s an inviting spot for any pizza enthusiast. The casual dress code and moderate noise level contribute to a relaxed dining experience, whether you're enjoying a meal on-site or opting for takeaway.

• Specialty Pizza: Dive into their remarkable Grandma Pie, a layered treasure that encapsulates the essence of homemade goodness, or try the indulgent Buffalo Chicken Pie, featuring crispy chicken strips tossed in hot sauce atop a rich tomato base. Each bite is a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor.
• Baked Ziti Pie: Celebrated for its tender ziti laced with savory homemade tomato sauce, mozzarella, and ricotta, this dish resonates with the comforting taste of Italian home cooking.
• Rustic Rolls & Calzones: The Pollo Alla Primavera is a must-try, marrying juicy chicken with a medley of seasonal vegetables, all sautéed to perfection.

Beyond pizza, A Touch of Italy excels in catering for various occasions. Their hot buffets such as the Seafood Marinara Tray and the Fried Calamari Tray provide an exquisite touch for gatherings, offering a taste of Italy that will leave your guests raving.

Customer reviews echo the sentiment that A Touch of Italy is synonymous with consistent quality. One patron, Laureen G., raves about the crunch and freshness of their pizza slices, while Lauren O. appreciates the reliable service that accompanies every visit. Ryan T. shares a mixed experience but underscores the restaurant’s potential with their standout salad pizza, hinting that perhaps one should skip the wings next time.

In essence, A Touch of Italy is not just a place to dine; it’s an experience. Their welcoming atmosphere, dedicated service, and delicious offerings make it a perfect spot for families, friends, or casual meetings over pizza. Whether looking to indulge in comforting Italian classics or simply enjoy a slice in the company of loved ones, A Touch of Italy promises a memorable culinary journey.

Give them a call at (631) 789-4066 for reservations or to order your next feast. With each visit, you’ll find a reason to come back for more of their delightful Italian fare.